{"contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"RachelMaddow"}

Talk Me Down! Long lines are a poll tax and where are the youth?

I know I know I know... I'm the last skeptic standing about Tuesday's election. I can read! I can hear!

But bear with me because I am so not convinced by the thing that was supposed to convince me about the process and disenfranchisement this time -- EARLY VOTING! It was supposed to make things better this time, right?

Well look at the lines.

In Georgia, people waited eight hours to cast a ballot today. There are reports of five hour waits in Indiana. In, North Carolina, the state board of elections ruled voting sites can stay open an extra four hours tomorrow to accommodate large crowds. And in Oklahoma the first voter at the Oklahoma County Election Board reportedly showed up at 4:30 a.m. even though the polls didn't open until 8 a.m.

Here's the thing: A day-long wait might as well be a poll tax. What does it cost you to wait eight hours? Is this the way our democracy works now? We're a country where only people who can afford to give up 20 percent of a week's pay are allowed to vote?

And while Obama is leading in the latest AP poll on early voting, the McCain campaign says they aren't worried. John McCain's deputy campaign manager Christian Ferry points to Nevada, a state where Kerry led Bush in early voting in 2004 - even though he ended up losing the state:

"In 2004, first time and new registrant Democrat voters made up 13 percent of all the early votes cast. Thus far in 2008, it's about 12.6 percent of all the early votes cast."

The McCain campaign says their internal polling numbers say Iowa is a dead heat. That's another place Kerry led in early voting, but ultimately lost the state to Bush. In Pennsylvania, here's what the McCain campaign is thinking - this is Christian Ferry again:

"In Pennsylvania, if you look at absentee ballot returns, the GOP is leading by about 56 percent to 44 percent in terms of returns. Younger Democrat voters in 2004 made up 22.9 percent of the absentee votes. Thus far in 2008, it's 14 percent of the -- 14.6 percent of the early -- absentee vote."

Want more? C'mon! Vegetables are good for you! We'll have dessert later, I promise!

An Orlando Sentinel analysis of early voting in Florida found that, "Young people are turning out in disproportionately low numbers ... making them the worst-performing demographic group."

The Sentinel says only 15 percent of early voters in Florida are under the age of 35, even though that group makes up a quarter of the electorate.

All that talk in the Democratic primaries about how young people were proving the haters wrong by actually showing up to vote even though everyone says they don't? Are the haters gonna turn out to actually be right?

Time for a talking down... clearly...

{"contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"RachelMaddow"}
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 4
{"commentId":3813439,"authorDomain":"WillFemia"}

Someone in the Twitter stream argued that long lines are a sign of good turnout. I'm inclined to think it's a sign that people are so sick of this election season they want to end it as soon as possible.

But to the task of talking you down, would you consider that these long lines have turned voting from a civic chore into a social phenomenon? People see those lines and feel absolutely left out. I'm thinking of starting a Web site that sells "I voted" stickers for losers who didn't bother to register but now feel totally left out as Americans everywhere are standing on line for hours to participate in this election event.

In that way, the lines may be the one thing that actually saves the youth vote. Personally, I don't believe in the youth vote. I remember hearing about it for Dean and Kerry and the youth left them both high and dry. All those rock the vote drives are only successful for their social cache. Which brings me to my point: If those lines act as a social pressure to be part of the voting line scene, the youth may actually bother to follow through. Lines beget lines.

{"commentId":3813439,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"WillFemia"}
  • 5 votes
Reply#1 - Fri Oct 31, 2008 10:57 PM EDT
{"commentId":3820355,"authorDomain":"georgiav24"}

Long lines !  SInce when long lines on voting centers is a problem?  To me, it shows

that people are eager and enthusiastic to do their fundamental duty and in doing

so they are willing to wait for hours.  This happens all over the world on every

election day!  But, here in United States we are not used to people voting.  We want

everyting easy and fast.  Instead of taking long lines as a negative, try to take

and talk about positively and encourage people to go out and vote despite the

long lines, the bad weather (in some states).  Encourage them to take water with

them, their i-pod (who every has one), their cell phone and maybe a book with them,

and some snacks.  Encourage people, make it a fun day not a chore day !

{"commentId":3820355,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"georgiav24"}
    #1.1 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 1:05 PM EDT
    {"commentId":3824296,"authorDomain":"pwtenny"}

    From what I understand Gov. Dean didn't have a ground game, he thought that maybe the Internet was the new GOTV, rather than just a part of it. Don't know about Kerry, I never felt like he had reached out to my generation but I voted for him all the same.

    I guess we'll see.

    {"commentId":3824296,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"pwtenny"}
    • 3 votes
    #1.2 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 5:47 PM EDT
    {"commentId":3842395,"authorDomain":"jules18"}

    Rachel, I think we need a system like at Disneyland to appeal to younger voters and it probably works for all ages. Voting stations need the Fast Pass, they get their assigned time to vote and come at that time. No need to stand in line and get to vote.

    {"commentId":3842395,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"jules18"}
    • 1 vote
    #1.3 - Mon Nov 3, 2008 1:28 AM EST
    {"commentId":3846083,"authorDomain":"ursapintada"}

    Two points about the 'youth vote' which is  College age...

    1. STUDENTS PROCRASTINATE!!!!! Of course they're not "studying" (voting) yet, the "test" isn't until tomorrow!

    2. The smart ones probably got absentee ballots.

    FYI, I'm in the 'youth' category (25 yrs old) and I voted early. The 30 min. line I was in this last Friday in Tucson, AZ was predominantly white and middle-aged, with only a handful of younger voters.

    And Rachel, to address the cost of voting for people that can't enjoy the same quick voting process I underwent, I say we make the 1st November of an election year a NATIONAL HOLIDAY... there are many other countries that do this and it would mandate employers to give their employees the proper time necessary to go to the polls and be a part of the democratic process in a meaningful and not so annoying-time-sucking-fruitless way.

    {"commentId":3846083,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"ursapintada"}
      #1.4 - Mon Nov 3, 2008 9:53 AM EST
      {"commentId":3850900,"authorDomain":"ursapintada"}

      let's not forget that the majority of the 'youth vote' are still in college... a.k.a. PROCRASTINATORS!!! plus, a lot of them might have been smart enough to opt for absentee ballots over waiting in lines

      We're slightly underestimating the competence of the youth and that they just might be smarter than the pundits on TV... remember how dead wrong the polls were in the primaries? it's because this is a new generation of election - anything goes.

      {"commentId":3850900,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"ursapintada"}
        #1.5 - Mon Nov 3, 2008 1:00 PM EST
        {"commentId":3860527,"authorDomain":"cuttinham"}

        Well said carrlodo.

        I'm 36, but attend college full-time as I'm switching careers mid-life, (gave up police work and hoping to be a drug & alcohol counselor).

        Every single person in that school who is old enough to vote is voting for Obama, (out of every single person I've talked with since Obama won the primary).

        What's more is that I'm smack dab right in the middle of a red state, (Nebraska), and even though most likely all 5 of our Electoral votes will go to McCain, it's not discouraging anyone from voting anyway.

        Right in the center of racist middle America, an entire new generation doesn't feel the same as the good old boys of yester-year.

        I'm a registered Republican who did not vote for Bush in 2000 or 2004.

        While my beliefs are strongly conservative, the rich people who hide behind Christianity and use scare tactics, (Obama will take your guns away!), do not speak for me.

        While I'm against abortion and believe strongly in the 2nd Amendment, it's not enough to pull me away from what is right and what is wrong.

        Bigotry and racism are wrong. The rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer is wrong. The corrupt system of government and lobbyists that allow corporations to run this country is wrong.

        We are ALL Americans, black, white, latino, asian, straight, gay or whatever you are.

        Almost all politicians look out for themselves only, and not the average American.

        I believe in Obama, and if he can deliver on 1/2 of what he says he can do, then the first black president in the history of this country could turn out to be one of the best American Presidents in my lifetime.

        The American people need to take this country back from the greedy politicians and the corporations who are their puppet masters.

        Obama is the catalyst for this change, and even conservative Republicans like me are waiting with open arms to embrace this change.

        Short Version: If McCain wins, I'm moving to Canada. :P

        {"commentId":3860527,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"cuttinham"}
        • 1 vote
        #1.6 - Mon Nov 3, 2008 8:30 PM EST
        {"commentId":3863260,"authorDomain":"kahaire"}

        Stay in the US - we need sensible people like you!

        {"commentId":3863260,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"kahaire"}
          #1.7 - Mon Nov 3, 2008 11:50 PM EST
          Reply
          {"commentId":3813467,"authorDomain":"racsharp"}

          after you check this out, we really need to talk about the bradely effect. That is why Mccain is smiling he knows that the lines are the new polls taxs.

          {"commentId":3813467,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"racsharp"}
            Reply#2 - Fri Oct 31, 2008 10:59 PM EDT
            {"commentId":3814204,"authorDomain":"mrgaijinsan"}

            Fortunately, I live in Washington, which along with Oregon, Colorado and California, are vote by mail states. (Permanent No Excuse Absentee) Your ballots arrive in the mail. SAT (fill in the bubble optical scan) type. No lines. No lost work. If you don't trust the mail, you can drop off at a voting station and you can check on line to see if it was received.

            You can also register anytime at a driver's license office and they ask you whenever you renew. All states should do this, no question.

            {"commentId":3814204,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"mrgaijinsan"}
              #2.1 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 12:14 AM EDT
              {"commentId":3814289,"authorDomain":"mrgaijinsan"}

              Fortunately, I live in Washington, which along with Oregon, Colorado and California, are vote by mail states. (Permanent No Excuse Absentee) Your ballots arrive in the mail. SAT (fill in the bubble optical scan) type. No lines. No lost work. If you don't trust the mail, you can drop off at a voting station and you can check on line to see if it was received.

              You can also register anytime at a driver's license office and they ask you whenever you renew. All states should do this, no question.

              {"commentId":3814289,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"mrgaijinsan"}
              • 1 vote
              #2.2 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 12:23 AM EDT
              {"commentId":3814436,"authorDomain":"mrgaijinsan"}

              In 2004, a few dead people voted, but that's been fixed now (I hope) and King County (Seattle) has a new high security warehouse to house all the scanners, designed by casino experts.

              {"commentId":3814436,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"mrgaijinsan"}
                #2.3 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 12:40 AM EDT
                {"commentId":3814458,"authorDomain":"mrgaijinsan"}

                Vote by mail states: 

                {"commentId":3814458,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"mrgaijinsan"}
                • 2 votes
                #2.4 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 12:42 AM EDT
                {"commentId":3842102,"authorDomain":"lindaeckhardt2008"}

                we need to have vote by mail everywhere like they do in Oregon.  it eliminates the long linesand it works.  Call up some Oregon officials and ask. 

                You're my shero, Rachel.  Go get 'em.  love your show...

                {"commentId":3842102,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"lindaeckhardt2008"}
                  #2.5 - Mon Nov 3, 2008 12:36 AM EST
                  {"commentId":3842228,"authorDomain":"jill-mossfamily"}

                  I'm glad that someone finally mentioned that there are states that vote by mail!  I'm in Oregon and I voted last Saturday (Oct 25), no lines, no waiting.  I sat at my kitchen table and filled out my ballot.  When I had a question about a ballot measure I could put down my pen and read the voter's pamphlet or look up stuff online.  My children got to watch me vote, as I talked to them about how important it is to be informed and exercise our right to vote.  Then I put my ballot in an envelope and put it in the mail.  I could have dropped it off at lots of different drop-off sites (schools, libraries, post offices, etc).  If I was a procrastinator I could fill it in in Tuesday and drop it off at the elections center that day.  Still no lines (except maybe a "drive-thru" line to drop off - there are an amazing amount of procrastinators out there!)

                  Why can't other states adopt this method?  It has proved to work well with minimal glitches (which are being addressed and fixed).  In Oregon, as of last Friday, 43% of registered voters had already voted!  Four days ahead of election day!  Nobody in the national media seems to realize that there are solutions to the long lines - vote by mail!!  Those of us on the west coast do have an idea worth listening to, once and awhile.

                  {"commentId":3842228,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"jill-mossfamily"}
                    #2.6 - Mon Nov 3, 2008 12:58 AM EST
                    Reply
                    {"commentId":3813496,"authorDomain":"grayhouse"}

                    "McCain campaign says they aren't worried."

                    Overt confidence is part of the game no matter how bad the picture actually is. Remember Karl Rove's prediction in the 2006 election? I'm with you, a skeptic too, but not so much regrading suppression or fraud as by some "swift boat" attack over the weekend.

                    {"commentId":3813496,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"grayhouse"}
                      Reply#3 - Fri Oct 31, 2008 11:03 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":3841126,"authorDomain":"kahaire"}

                      Well, we now know what the attack attempt is - this question over Obama's aunt's immigrant status.   Don't know why it should matter, since she's not the one running for office.  

                      {"commentId":3841126,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"kahaire"}
                        #3.1 - Sun Nov 2, 2008 10:33 PM EST
                        Reply
                        {"commentId":3813534,"authorDomain":"losta"}

                        Uh oh...here we go again. Again, nothing but the coming of November 5th will talk you down.

                        It seems alot of people are voting early, those long lines you showed, news shows seem to buzz about it. How long has early voting been around? 

                        Maybe the 35 and under's want the election day experience? Maybe they are looking forward to November 4th like the release of a new iPhone at Apple? Maybe they don't know?

                        Keep- keeping us on our toes, twitter up the vote, keep talking. Have faith in us and keep your fingers crossed. 

                        Thanks for keeping our brains occupied while we worry with you.

                        {"commentId":3813534,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"losta"}
                        • 3 votes
                        Reply#4 - Fri Oct 31, 2008 11:07 PM EDT
                        {"commentId":3813664,"authorDomain":"bendinah"}

                        Rachael-I am after you again-your paranoia just does not feel good......especially when you justify it because of comments from the McCain campaign.  Rachael, they are LIARS....they will say anything, literally anything if they think it will help John McCain claim power.........that is why they will lose so badly.  The right wing of the GOP is finished.......watch the landslide for Obama that they have created....and please cheer up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

                        {"commentId":3813664,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"bendinah"}
                          Reply#5 - Fri Oct 31, 2008 11:20 PM EDT
                          {"commentId":3834908,"authorDomain":"mjf-pdx"}

                          Bill, anyone who is naive enough to think Obama will win, for sure, should pay more attention to a few things:

                          -The tens of thousand who have been purged. 

                          -There seems to be a lack of youth coming out as we were promised they would, and

                          -Republicans are VERY GOOD at cheating [recall the owners of the voting machines are rabid Republicans who promised and delivered Bush the vote.....by fiat].

                          Don't kid yourself......this last minute "we can't let the most liberal Senator get a mandate"........this fear of actually giving Obama something to work with WILL likely work for McCain - and that's IF Obama is even elected. 

                          No, this election will be a mess.  Why?

                          After the last eight years, I am convinced that Americans are truly ignorant.  They WANT to be told how to think, plus they don't seem to care that Bush has raped our Constitution.....most don't even KNOW what it says!!!

                          Until that changes, we are likely to see more misery instead of any..... change :o{

                          {"commentId":3834908,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"mjf-pdx"}
                            #5.1 - Sun Nov 2, 2008 12:45 PM EST
                            {"commentId":3840743,"authorDomain":"wizardweiss1"}

                            I feel sorry for you.  You are right, "they are liars!"  Problem is, the they is politicians, both parties, both canidates, one as bad as the other.  Add yourself to the list.  You're lying to yourself.

                            {"commentId":3840743,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"wizardweiss1"}
                            • 1 vote
                            #5.2 - Sun Nov 2, 2008 9:52 PM EST
                            {"commentId":3852664,"authorDomain":"ehr"}

                            I think there may be a quantitative and qualitative differenced in the lying done by both sides.   But without any way to measure the lying to make some kind of comparison then you may be lying to yourself by holding the belief that both candidates are "as bad as the other".

                            My sense, and this is just an impression, is that the McCain campaign's  lie are  bigger and more frequent...but I wouldn't bet my bike on that claim. 

                            {"commentId":3852664,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"ehr"}
                              #5.3 - Mon Nov 3, 2008 2:06 PM EST
                              Reply
                              {"commentId":3813681,"authorDomain":"cocallaghan"}

                              You are not the only skeptic, I'm still right there with you but I'm actually going to try to talk you down this time!  I'm under 35 (just barely) and voted the other day here in Florida.  While there was only one other person in the two hour line that looked to be under 35, just about everyone I know has voted or will be voting.  Many of them are also going out door to door encouraging people to vote and others are organizing car pools for those generally confined to their homes.  I also know people who have given up there homes to Obama volunteers from out of state.

                              For the last few weeks, I have received daily texts to my cell phone and calls to my home phone from the campaign encouraging me to vote early, offering me a ride to the polls if I can't get there myself, or just offering to assist in any way necessary.  While these phone calls would generally drive me up the walls, I enjoy receiving them, because it means if I am getting this many calls, so is every other registered Democrat in this county where we are outnumbered by Republicans by 2 to 1!

                              I am still as skeptical as you seem to be, and I probably will be until Nov 5th.  But, I've never before experienced a Democratic presence or sense of unity like this in FL.  That has to be a positive sign right? Okay, maybe I did not really do a good job of talking you down this time either!

                              {"commentId":3813681,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"cocallaghan"}
                              • 2 votes
                              Reply#6 - Fri Oct 31, 2008 11:21 PM EDT
                              {"commentId":3813687,"authorDomain":"live4peace2"}

                              How many of you are really worried about the idea of Sarah Palin leading this country someday?  Yes I know, I can't wrap my mind around it either but stranger things have happened. We can't take this possibility for granted. Don't think for one minute that she does not have her own agenda. She wants power, and fame, and fortune. She could be a heartbeat away from the oval office. DONT LET THAT HAPPEN. We all would be doomed...

                              {"commentId":3813687,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"live4peace2"}
                                Reply#7 - Fri Oct 31, 2008 11:22 PM EDT
                                {"commentId":3815588,"authorDomain":"kahaire"}

                                I would actually be willing to bet that if McCain and Palin get elected, that Palin would wind up as President before McCain could finish his term.  Given his age and history of cancer, it is quite easy to believe he might not live to finish his term.  Which is why his choice for Vice President is SO important - and so bad.  

                                The Palin record:

                                When she became Mayor of Wasilia, the town had no debt.  When she left office, the town had over $1 million in debt, due from legal fees resulting from her starting construction of a sports complex on land the town did not yet own.  As Governor, she only denounced the Bridge to Nowhere only after Congress put a stop to it, but she kept the money anyway (that one really blows my mind).  We all should know about TrooperGate by now.  The gas pipeline that she and McCain talk about all the time is not built yet, and won't be for some time - if ever.  The company contracted to build it has NEVER successfully completed a pipeline before.  And there have been questions about the bidding process for that project.  And then there's the Alaska National Guard.  The Alaska National Guard has the lowest preparedness rating of all the state National Guards in the country.  They are not considered deployable, and are not even capable of properly handling a state emergency.  And she has no experience with or understanding of foreign policy issues.

                                Palin's time in office has been marked by incompetence.  There is no way this woman is qualified to be Vice President, let alone President.  She has proven herself to be fiscally irresponsible.  She couldn't keep her town financially solvent - how is she supposed to bring fiscal responsibility to Washington and the country if she can't do it in a town of less than 9000 people.  She's ethically challenged, and has used her office to aid her personal interests.  If she is incapable of properly negotiating and executing contracts, how is she supposed to negotiate with world leaders?  And if she can't properly manage the National Guard in Alaska, and doesn't understand foreign policy issues, how can she be Commander-In-Chief?

                                This is something that I think about regularly.  The idea of Sarah Palin as President makes my blood run cold.

                                {"commentId":3815588,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"kahaire"}
                                • 2 votes
                                #7.1 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 3:01 AM EDT
                                {"commentId":3816143,"authorDomain":"nova1972e"}

                                Palin in the oval office receiving an exorcism before taking an important decision?

                                Scary.

                                And by the way, why the long lines? Why the people in the US have to wait all that long just to vote?

                                I am Greek and I voted about 10 times in my life. I usually finish within 20'-30' from the moment I enter the waiting line and a couple of times it took me longer to give my id, take the ballots (we still use paper ballots), go to the voting booth, vote, take my id back and sign, than waiting in the line. And we usually have a 70-80% turnout and a single day of election.

                                We actually do something better than you guys!

                                {"commentId":3816143,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"nova1972e"}
                                  #7.2 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 4:50 AM EDT
                                  Reply
                                  {"commentId":3813699,"authorDomain":"live4peace2"}

                                  The youth of today seem to get the idea that their very own future is at stake in this election, but some how I can't help but feel that most still take it for granted.  I pray that the youth voter turnout is incredible, and that I am pleasantly surprised, but history does tell us we can not count on anything.  I am more than pleased that Obama seems to understand fully that he can not take anything for granted either. Polls are never completely the truth, and unfortunately not even the votes reflect the truth either as we have seen before. BUT WE MUST MAKE OUR VOICES HEARD, AND VOTE!!!  Our future, our way of life, our liberties fully depend on it.

                                  {"commentId":3813699,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"live4peace2"}
                                  • 1 vote
                                  Reply#8 - Fri Oct 31, 2008 11:23 PM EDT
                                  {"commentId":3814121,"authorDomain":"konachrisman"}

                                  Why do all the political pundits believe the youth vote belongs to Obama?  Most college students are not busting their butts (not to mention spending a lot of future dollars) to become “middle class” wager earners.  I don’t think they’ll vote for a candidate who is on record as saying “I’ll spread the wealth around”.  It’s their (future) wealth Obama intends to spread around.  There are two kinds of voters.  The rich and those who want to become rich.  Obama will make it much tougher for those who want to create their own wealth to do so.  Most college students aren’t there to become “middle class”!

                                  {"commentId":3814121,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"konachrisman"}
                                    Reply#9 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 12:05 AM EDT
                                    {"commentId":3814236,"authorDomain":"hlnhi"}

                                    I am at an age called elderly(groan)..but I have to say I am impressed with these young people today...I believe they will come through. They are smart, thoughtful and involved. They don't seem to care what color you are or what your sexual orientation is (I know, I know, there are exceptions..but overall I think they are miles ahead of my generation...and we had John and Robert to inspire us)..These kids might look a little funny to me but as I have watched them work on the campaign...they know what they want politically and it is not more of the same. They are tired of the disregard for the Constitution and the rights of citizens... I am so optimistic about these young people.. They will come through...

                                    {"commentId":3814236,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"hlnhi"}
                                    • 5 votes
                                    Reply#10 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 12:17 AM EDT
                                    {"commentId":3822012,"authorDomain":"bgates43"}

                                    I second your assessment about young people, Helen.

                                    As another old person, I've got time to stand it line and time to read political blogs. One of Rachel's comments in this blog scares me:

                                    A day-long wait might as well be a poll tax.

                                    I hadn't though of it that way before, but it strikes me as true and a real danger.

                                    The other thing I'm worried about is young voters turning out. That remains an open question. I hope they do. There is evidence they're going to. But I need to see it to be entirely comfortable.  Long lines, inertia, a believe their vote won't be needed and other factors may keep the youth vote down. I pray it doesn't. It's so important this year for the Obama coalition and the local candidates who need a big turnout.

                                    {"commentId":3822012,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"bgates43"}
                                    • 3 votes
                                    #10.1 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 3:00 PM EDT
                                    Reply
                                    {"commentId":3814265,"authorDomain":"jlombardo57"}

                                    Rachel... would it be OK with you if we just won ?....too much to ask ?

                                    For a Liberal you seem exceptionally unimpressed with Barack Obama, his campaign, his supporters....actually you seem more like Greta.

                                    So why am I still watching your show ?.

                                    {"commentId":3814265,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"jlombardo57"}
                                      Reply#11 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 12:21 AM EDT
                                      {"commentId":3819427,"authorDomain":"hlnhi"}

                                      Grace...RAchel has alegit concern...This is a tiem of instant gratification....standing in long lines is not instant gratification. BUT more seriously, if it is costing you a day's pay(or your job) it seems to me you might be less likely to stand in line for so long. IT is a serious problem.

                                      You are still watching Rachel's show because she is witty and quite bright. Her style is different from Molly Ivins---whom I miss but Rachel is very good at what she does. Now go to on Rachel and enjoy...No more insults with that silly Greta person/lawyer

                                      {"commentId":3819427,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"hlnhi"}
                                      • 2 votes
                                      #11.1 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 12:10 PM EDT
                                      Reply
                                      {"commentId":3814456,"authorDomain":"ladyapr"}

                                      I have to disagree with you Grace.  I saw the excitement Rachel had before she interviewed Obama.  She seemed impressed because he is an impressive man.  But anyway.  I went to vote early this past Monday and there weren't a lot of under 35 year olds in the line (but Seminole county is staunchly Republican so I wan't surprised.)  Orange county was probably a whole lot better.  I'm hoping and praying that the young people get their butts in gear and show up, at least on Tuesday.  Don't let the "geezers" in their thirties like me show you up!!  Rachel, you're a worry-wart like my mom used to say and I'm with you!! I've got butterflies in my stomach and their getting worse the closer we get to election day.  I try to talk myself down by repeating my mantra......If Barack Obama is meant to be POTUS, nothing in the world can stop it...keep repeating it, it works.

                                      {"commentId":3814456,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"ladyapr"}
                                      • 2 votes
                                      Reply#12 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 12:42 AM EDT
                                      {"commentId":3840667,"authorDomain":"djshiva"}

                                      Crap.  30s is geezer age now?  Damn.  Here I was deceiving myself into thinking that somehow I still qualified as the "youth vote".

                                      *Sigh*

                                      {"commentId":3840667,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"djshiva"}
                                        #12.1 - Sun Nov 2, 2008 9:43 PM EST
                                        {"commentId":3841235,"authorDomain":"kahaire"}

                                        Well, at 28, I apparently still qualify as the youth vote.  And I voted on Oct. 16th, the first day of early voting in NC.  And since I am unemployed due to the crappy economy, I have been spending lots of time volunteering on political campaigns.

                                        I do agree that having to spend hours in line is as bad as a poll tax, though I also had not thought of it that way before.  We need our voting system changed and upgraded to allow for high voter turnout.  

                                        {"commentId":3841235,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"kahaire"}
                                        • 1 vote
                                        #12.2 - Sun Nov 2, 2008 10:45 PM EST
                                        Reply
                                        {"commentId":3814851,"authorDomain":"grrrlromeo"}

                                        Rachel... shhh... you're freaking out the people that live in states that don't have early voting.

                                        But I totally get it. We thought we had it in the bag in 2004, and "we got spanked." People started celebrating too early and dropped the ball. I know these wait lines should be covered by the media so we can get this stuff fixed.

                                        But, perhaps in these last few days, we should be rallying the people in the lines. Cheer them on. Attach pride in staying in line like it's a fight for the right to vote. It's totally awesome that people are staying line!

                                        Then on Wednesday we can start lodging our complaints over the voting process. I don't think we should start characterizing the wait in line as work just yet. It's kinda discouraging.

                                        What was voting like in 1992? I remember everything about that election, except for the actual voting since I was 15.

                                        {"commentId":3814851,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"grrrlromeo"}
                                        • 1 vote
                                        Reply#13 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 1:26 AM EDT
                                        {"commentId":3841268,"authorDomain":"kahaire"}

                                        I was 12.  My only memory of that election is of the first debate between Clinton, Bush, and Ross Perot.  My school assigned watching the debate as our only homework for the evening.

                                        {"commentId":3841268,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"kahaire"}
                                          #13.1 - Sun Nov 2, 2008 10:47 PM EST
                                          Reply
                                          {"commentId":3814952,"authorDomain":"jmcksage"}

                                          I agree that the needlessly long lines are a poll tax.  If it's going to cost you a day's pay to vote this way, doesn't it make sense to cut the cost by hiring someone at minimum wage to hold your place in line?  Is this legal?  Just drop off your stand-in at the voting station, give them your phone number, and go back to work for a few hours.  It's another way of spreading the wealth and building the economy back up from the bottom.  A win/win/win solution.

                                          {"commentId":3814952,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"jmcksage"}
                                          • 2 votes
                                          Reply#14 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 1:35 AM EDT
                                          {"commentId":3815152,"authorDomain":"tjapple"}

                                          oh ye of little faith.  i said obama with a mandate.  polls haven't closed.  polls close in another 60-70 hours.  too much hyperventilating over polling.  if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, it's going to be obama.  barack obama is not john kerry and let's agree with mccain--he ain't george bush...or karl rove...or james carville or stephanopoulus.  obama with a mandate.  we can study the demographics of the turnout later.  the election will close and be tight but it will be obama with a mandate.

                                          {"commentId":3815152,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"tjapple"}
                                            Reply#15 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 1:58 AM EDT
                                            {"commentId":3815207,"authorDomain":"MrsBrady"}

                                            Maybe they are waiting till Election Day to go in groups or if they are anything like my girls they put everything off till the last second . My Mother who never voted before in her whole life voted yesterday for Obama .

                                            {"commentId":3815207,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"MrsBrady"}
                                            • 3 votes
                                            Reply#16 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 2:04 AM EDT
                                            {"commentId":3815433,"authorDomain":"jmaan33"}

                                            Guys:  I'm new to this site but I've been watching the RM Show since it started.  It's fabulous.  Tonight, I managed to read an article which completely scared the living sh*t  out of me.  Can someone please talk me down????????????????  It's titled ""Cyber Security Expert Says KingPin Attack Benefited Bush"

                                            by John Michael Spinelli of the Ohio News

                                            Here is the link: 

                                            {"commentId":3815433,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"jmaan33"}
                                              Reply#17 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 2:37 AM EDT
                                              {"commentId":3815440,"authorDomain":"jmaan33"}

                                              {"commentId":3815440,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"jmaan33"}
                                                Reply#18 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 2:37 AM EDT
                                                {"commentId":3815562,"authorDomain":"davidrain"}

                                                The first year I was eligible to vote was 1972, I was an 18-year-old college freshman and it was the first year 18-year-olds could vote.

                                                There was only one precinct near the university, and the waiting line was about 4 hours.

                                                My classes were scattered throughout the day, and I had an evening class, as well, so there were no four-hour breaks between my classes. I waited about two hours in the late-afternoon and finally left without voting when it was time for class.

                                                I've never missed an election since then, even a school board election, but when I hear the talk about young people not voting, it reminds me of my experience.

                                                Rep. Debbie Wasserman-Schultz said she hadn't heard anyone say they wouldn't be able to vote, and I hope she's correct, but I think about students with classes and a job, working people with two or more jobs, elderly or infirm people, and others who just aren't able to stand for several hours or miss work or school obligations for a four-to-six-hour period.

                                                Of course there are ways around that, such as a mail-in absentee ballot, but it's too late for that in most places. By the time people discover the lines will be too long for them vote in person, the mail-in process can't be completed in time.

                                                It's just inexcusable that we don't have systems in place with national standards that ensure everyone can vote, even if they aren't able to stand in line for hours.

                                                {"commentId":3815562,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"davidrain"}
                                                  Reply#19 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 2:56 AM EDT
                                                  {"commentId":3815690,"authorDomain":"dianern"}

                                                  Rachel... the solution to long voting lines? The Oregon Plan. We have voted entirely by mail for years. NO standing in line... no lost work. I got my ballot in the mail on October 17th. One hour later it was filled out and I drove to the drop box at my local city hall and dropped it off. Done! Another advantage to this? When the signature on the outer envelope is checked with the signature on record with the state database, it is recorded as voted. Any group doing voter turnout can get daily updates of who has returned ballots. Once your ballot is in, you quit getting phone calls reminding you to vote or trying to persuade you how to vote. A lot of people who were opposed to our method when we started it, argued that it would be riddled with fraudulent voters, poor voter turnout and that folks would be upset to lose that comaraderie and patriotic feel of going to the polling place on election day to vote. No fraud has occured, voter turnout has increased dramatically year after year, voter suppression efforts do not work with us and no one laments missing out on standing in line for 5-8 hours to vote. Hope the new Democrat majority looks at Oregon as a model for change across the country.

                                                  {"commentId":3815690,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"dianern"}
                                                    Reply#20 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 3:16 AM EDT
                                                    {"commentId":3815795,"authorDomain":"sewardg"}

                                                    About early voting

                                                    Here in CA there is only one early voting location in each county, at the county seat.  It is not surprising that there are long lines, what with people being worried if they will have a problem at the polls.  Young people especially might not have the time to wait in these lines, between classes and rigid jobs.

                                                    Come Tuesday there will be many polling places in each city and town, as there should be for early voting.

                                                    The voters will turn out, young and old.

                                                    {"commentId":3815795,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"sewardg"}
                                                      Reply#21 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 3:30 AM EDT
                                                      {"commentId":3816194,"authorDomain":"nova1972e"}

                                                      I am Greek and have to admit, these long lines are a strange thing to me.

                                                      Whenever we have elections it takes no more than 20 to 30 minutes to vote, we have a 75% turnout and we have a single day of elections. Plus we don't have to register, we all are registered automatically since the day we turn 18. We don't have to do anything just grab our id and go to vote.

                                                      If we can do it, it's not that hard at all...

                                                      {"commentId":3816194,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"nova1972e"}
                                                        Reply#22 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 5:04 AM EDT
                                                        {"commentId":3817535,"authorDomain":"taiwanjohn"}

                                                        You said it! Although I vote in Iowa (by absentee ballot), I've been living in Taiwan for many years, and the way they handle voting here is an example we Americans could learn from.

                                                        All polling places use paper ballots. After the polls close, the ballot boxes are collected at the township level. There, they are opened *in public* and the ballots are counted *in public*, with representatives of the parties and the media in attendance. They hold up each ballot, show it to the "audience", and call out the votes. A second election worker affirms each call, and it is tallied on a board in full view. In a country with 23 million population, the entire process takes a few hours. (I've heard that they have a similar system in Canada, but I don't know any details.)

                                                        Another nice thing about elections here is that the date is flexible, and is traditionally set on a Saturday, to allow more people to vote without missing work.

                                                        Granted, they have their own set of election problems here (google "chen shui-bian 2004 recount" for example). They don't have any mechanism for absentee ballots -- you MUST travel to your "home" precinct to vote -- but despite this they still have generally higher levels of participation than America has in the past few decades.

                                                        In Iowa, by the way, we switched from mechanical voting machines to paper-ballot scanners in the 1980's... seems a pretty sensible solution to me. I can't imagine why more states don't use them.

                                                        --jrd

                                                        {"commentId":3817535,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"taiwanjohn"}
                                                          #22.1 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 9:38 AM EDT
                                                          {"commentId":3823190,"authorDomain":"msjanemas"}

                                                          Don't have to register because you automatically are when you turn 18.  Isn't that incredible... that the United States who charges other countries of voter fraud refuses to make our election and electorial process simple?  And they have the audacity to over see third world elections.. tisk.  This country should be embarassed.   This brokendown system has to do with creating unnecessary jobs.  Government has a history of taking the long road to get things done.

                                                          When I hear european leaders discuss issues like the way they handle their market crisis in public, one wonders how the heck did the US ever became a powerful nation?  Money, corruption and invasions. 

                                                          {"commentId":3823190,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"msjanemas"}
                                                          • 1 vote
                                                          #22.2 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 4:20 PM EDT
                                                          {"commentId":3841312,"authorDomain":"kahaire"}

                                                          I've thought for some time that anyone who is a US citizen should be able to vote.  Just have proof of citizenship, since we all have to have some kind of proof of work eligibility in order to get a job.  What we need is a database that would have all citizen's voter information so that all we need is some form of ID.

                                                          {"commentId":3841312,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"kahaire"}
                                                          • 1 vote
                                                          #22.3 - Sun Nov 2, 2008 10:50 PM EST
                                                          {"commentId":3843967,"authorDomain":"grayhouse"}

                                                          "I've thought for some time that anyone who is a US citizen should be able to vote."

                                                          I've thought for a long time that voters need to pass a basic civics test before being allowed to vote. Too many voters haven't got a clue as to how our government operates, or the actual responsibilities of the position they are voting on. One question could be "what are the duties of the VPOTUS?"

                                                          {"commentId":3843967,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"grayhouse"}
                                                            #22.4 - Mon Nov 3, 2008 7:43 AM EST
                                                            {"commentId":3855965,"authorDomain":"kahaire"}

                                                            I think you need to give that civics test to Palin.  She certainly can't answer that question properly.

                                                            I agree that lack of civic understanding my US citizens is a HUGE problem.  But I want a system where there is no way to purge people from the voter rolls.  There have been too many instance throughout history of politicians manipulating the system to benefit themselves and their party, by both parties.

                                                            {"commentId":3855965,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"kahaire"}
                                                            • 1 vote
                                                            #22.5 - Mon Nov 3, 2008 4:31 PM EST
                                                            {"commentId":3866382,"authorDomain":"nova1972e"}

                                                            "I've thought for a long time that voters need to pass a basic civics test before being allowed to vote. Too many voters haven't got a clue as to how our government operates, or the actual responsibilities of the position they are voting on. One question could be "what are the duties of the VPOTUS?""

                                                            Maybe, but this is not democracy. In a democracy EVERYBODY has the right to vote. Even if they are not ready, even if they don't know anything about the constitution or their civil rights, that's the central idea around democracy. It's up to the state then to give to the citizens the proper preparation for them to become good voters.

                                                            So when the people vote for candidates like G.W. Bush Jr. they can only blame themselves. Both the state and the people.

                                                            What you are descriving is something different.

                                                            {"commentId":3866382,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"nova1972e"}
                                                            • 1 vote
                                                            #22.6 - Tue Nov 4, 2008 8:46 AM EST
                                                            {"commentId":3867016,"authorDomain":"grayhouse"}

                                                            I don't necessarily disagree with you Nodas. But voting in a democracy, in my opinion, is both a right and a responsibility. The right is granted, but the responsibility is not required. Someone pointed out in another post that voting in Australia is required by law. Maybe the state giving the proper preparation to become a good voter should be a mandatory test similar to those required to become a naturalized citizen. Our country makes the responsibility of voting too easy for native citizens and we all pay a price for that.

                                                            {"commentId":3867016,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"grayhouse"}
                                                              #22.7 - Tue Nov 4, 2008 9:19 AM EST
                                                              {"commentId":3867461,"authorDomain":"losta"}

                                                              There should be more information available that is non biased non ad based. I used to live in California and about a month or so before each election I would get a several hundred page pamphlet giving the argument for and argument against each issue (as well as a response to each argument) on the ballot and there are always plenty of Propositions in California both state and citywide.

                                                              It was alot of reading, often too much, but it was good information. I don't remember if there was information on candidates stands but perhaps a current CA resident can tell us.

                                                              I think at this point something like this should be available on the internet and people should be encouraged to go to the site and think for themselves so they are not overly influenced by slanted news commentary or guidance for their religious groups.

                                                              {"commentId":3867461,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"losta"}
                                                                #22.8 - Tue Nov 4, 2008 9:36 AM EST
                                                                {"commentId":3873577,"authorDomain":"nova1972e"}

                                                                Good education is very important, make everybody finish at least highschool and make an effort to teach them as much as you can about how the political system works, about rights, responsability.

                                                                It's not gonna work for everyone, but if you manage to make it work for the majority it will work, most of the times at least. Democracy works with large numbers. It's not perfect but at least it's the less non-perfect system we have.

                                                                By the way in Italy and Greece (I lived in Italy till 2003) TV ads -most of the times- are not permitted (majorities change, laws change) and when they are there is a limit. On the other side there are programs to every channel but specially to the state TV, where representatives of every party take time explaining their program. 

                                                                And both in Greece and in Italy the elections last a month and a half. A year? Pheww you Americans when you do things you really do them BIG!

                                                                {"commentId":3873577,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"nova1972e"}
                                                                  #22.9 - Tue Nov 4, 2008 1:01 PM EST
                                                                  {"commentId":3882843,"authorDomain":"kahaire"}

                                                                  In NC, you have to take a class in government and economics in order to graduate high school.  Not sure how much it helps, because historically I have not heard a lot of people analyzing the issues and fact-checking things they are told in church, in the paper, or on tv.  But at least it's a start.  I have to note, this year seems to be different with the younger generation.  More of them that I talk to seem to be fact-checking, and given the huge youth population in this state, that's going to have a big impact.

                                                                  In NC, we also have a voter guide that is published and mailed to everyone before early voting begins.  It's also available on the internet.  It only includes congressional and local elections, and the info is incomplete, but again, it's a start.

                                                                  {"commentId":3882843,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"kahaire"}
                                                                  • 1 vote
                                                                  #22.10 - Tue Nov 4, 2008 5:48 PM EST
                                                                  Reply
                                                                  {"commentId":3816492,"authorDomain":"maryschutte"}

                                                                  Gil:  You came closest to talking ME down, at least.  I hadn't considered how many more polling places will be open on Tuesday. 

                                                                  {"commentId":3816492,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"maryschutte"}
                                                                    Reply#23 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 6:43 AM EDT
                                                                    {"commentId":3816563,"authorDomain":"Leesa"}

                                                                    Hey Rachel...I feel ya dog! I go through the same fits and starts. I start out by reading/watching my feel-good sources then move on to the pundits and polls, by this time I'm scared witless and feel all is lost, "and we were soo close" I wail.

                                                                    Suddenly, my dad (who has lost all patience with me by now) throws a glass of ice-cold water in my face and shouts "tranquilla, boba (Spanish for 'calm down, dummy')..." and slowly the room comes back into focus.

                                                                    Seriously though, this is Democracy with a capital D...it's messy and unnerving and unfortuantly, fraught with humaness. It's acutally a beautiful process to witness however, if you're a refugee from a communist country, where in 1968 you fled with 90 lbs of belongings, leaving behind everything you held dear.

                                                                    This IS the greatest country on Earth and my 70 year old father, a Cuban refugee and American citizen waited in a 4 hour line yesterday to vote with the biggest smile on his face...life is good...have faith!

                                                                    {"commentId":3816563,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"Leesa"}
                                                                    • 1 vote
                                                                    Reply#24 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 7:08 AM EDT
                                                                    {"commentId":3818531,"authorDomain":"curioustoknow"}

                                                                    http://www.gainesvilletimes.com/news/article/10652/

                                                                    Yes, long lines is a voting rights issue.  And meanwhile in some places it's also becoming a community event. How are people handling the long lines in your neck of the woods?

                                                                    {"commentId":3818531,"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189","authorDomain":"curioustoknow"}
                                                                      Reply#25 - Sat Nov 1, 2008 11:03 AM EDT
                                                                      Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 4
                                                                      {"canLink":false,"threadId":"405779","isPrivate":false}
                                                                      Leave a Comment:
                                                                      You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                                                      As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
                                                                      {"threadId":"405779","contentId":"2061189"}
                                                                      Start TrackingStart Tracking
                                                                      Stop TrackingStop Tracking
                                                                      RSS feedSyndicate this contentRecent Articles & Seeds
                                                                      RachelMaddow's Latest Comments
                                                                      No comments have been posted yet.
                                                                      RachelMaddow's Recent Votes
                                                                      RachelMaddow has not voted for any articles or seeds yet.
                                                                      Comments & Feedback
                                                                      – Show More